Tag Archives: purity culture

On Tuesday, May 29, 2007, LJers – users of the then-popular blogging site Livejournal – woke up to find that their Friends lists were showing a large number of names that had been crossed out, or strikethrough ‘ed.

It turned out that LiveJournal had permanently suspended over 500 journals based on the users’ interest lists. Interests that were likely to get a journal banned included but were not limited to: child pornography, incest, pedophilia, rape, domestic violence, BDSM, prostitution. Journals that listed things like murder, crime, drugs, cocaine, theft, tax evasion or election fraud among their creators’ interests were not banned: interests related to sexual crime were the targets.

Among the deleted ljs were RPG journals, book discussion groups [1], rape survivor blogs[2], and fannish groups, including the large and popular Harry Potter fanfiction community Pornish Pixies, which was an age-restricted community for adult HP fanfiction.

Please read about strikethrough and boldthrough if you are not already familiar with them.

These mass-censorship events destroyed whole fanfiction and rp communities, and were the major motivating events behind the creation of Archive of Our Own and Dreamwidth.

Take a look at this person who is saying the quiet part out loud.

It’s not that they think proshippers cause harm, it’s that they’re weird.

Not only does this person think that being weird is bad, they think you shouldn’t be allowed to be weird near other people.

❤️‍🔥 There is nothing special and bad about sex in fiction.

❤️‍🔥 Abusive, ‘nasty’, illegal, or taboo sex in fiction isn’t any worse than anything else bad in fiction.

❤️‍🔥Reading or writing about a type of sex in fiction will not program you to want that sex in real life.

❤️‍🔥 It will not program you to think that bad sex is okay in real life.

❤️‍🔥 Reading writing or enjoying a type of sex in fiction does not mean you want to have that sex in real life.

❤️‍🔥 Sex is not a special magical category by itself.

❤️‍🔥 If you claim sexual fiction causes rape, pedophilia or incest IRL you are saying the same thing as “videogames cause violence.”

Just a reminder:

♦ Any content that is not against Tumblr’s TOS is allowed in the ‘main tag’ of a relevant fandom.

♦ It is not your duty or right to police the content of tumblr’s tags beyond what breaks tumblr’s TOS.

♦ If you don’t like something that’s in a tag, block or filter it.

♦ You are not the tag police.

dead-pidove-do-not-eat:

“Liking taboo thing in fiction is FINE, but god forbid u make it SEXY and HORNY!!!”

Not 2 be rude but what the fuck. Just because there are erotic elements and shit added doesn’t suddenly make people lose all sense of morality.

This idea that “desire” is this all powerful feeling that can make you lose control and disregard morals is an argument created to protect rapists. It attempts to absolve guilt of violation from parties who disregard other parties consent (or disregard if they even CAN consent.) by incorrectly smearing sexual desire and the strength of that desire as something that can even overpower self control, it gives a justification and leeway as to why a party violated another parties consent.

Sexual desire and horniness don’t work like that, have never worked like that and never WILL work like that. And to even entertain the argument as valid even for a second? Is fucking dangerous. I get that these sexual feelings are scary especially when they’re geared towards something “strange” and “weird” or morally reprehensible irl. But falling back on arguments used to perpetuate rape culture to try and justify why it’s “wrong” when all it does is cause personal discomfort is like… actually really bad.

‘i can’t believe you’re sexualizing porn!’… these people got a brain the size of a chewed up wad of bubblegum. Do they know what words mean? Or do they just want to say ‘you being horny over porn makes me disgusted’ but sounding like some sorta hot take

Fancops are always implicitly saying, “I, an upstanding and moral person enjoy this pornography and violence on a purely intellectual level, while I am positive you, a filthy degenerate, are getting off to it.”

*context note: this post is discussing fancops who enjoy explicit/erotic otome games about underage characters.

“What if a child sees this content”What if a child sees your fucking constant stalking, harassment, death threats, and promotion of real world harm as “jokes” traumatizing them or scarring them in a way that makes it harder for them to tell actual danger from actual friends.Look at your own glass house antis /:

Fancops fall into two categories:

Hypocrites who don’t realize that what they’re saying is that bad things in fiction influence people, but modeling back actions in reality doesn’t influence people.

and Terrorists, who actively endorse violence and believe that it is a social good to encourage people to spread hate, and violent language; to stalk, harass and threaten people who have different opinions from them.

*gestures to the whole anti/fancop community* You know what this is? Mob mentality at its worst.Btw thanks for everything you do, hope you have a nice day!

Not to be all relating fandom stuff to historical events, but it really reminds me of the little girls who started the Salem witch trials.

And thank you, we hope you have a nice day too! <3

In what way does being told your ship is cringe ever fucking compare to puritanical abuse because this is actually really fucking disgusting and offensive. Sure it’s not harmful and you’re not a bad person, but this is offensive as a victim for puritanical abuse. The sheer audacity to compare these two things is astounding and makes me question if you know what puritinism is.Puritanism is being told you’re gross and broken and filthy because you were abused as a fucking child. Puritanism is being told you’re disgusting and evil and deserve further abuse because you became hypersexual due to trauma. Puritanism is objectification or afab bodies. Puritanism is abusive. Someone being a dick to you online once is not the fucking same as so many peoples trauma. You are downplaying trauma by daring to compare the two.You can talk about issues with “antis” (let’s be real you’re referring to alt-righters they’re not even in fandom because anyone we’ve seen with the actual anti tags are not saying this it’s only the fucking rightholds) engaging in REAL puritanism but your post is implying the “your ship is kinda cringe” takes are abywhere near the same and that is so fucking irresponsible.

marshemillow:

I don’t even want to dignify this with a response. What is your fucking definition of abuse, because last I checked, feeding people sewing needles, doxxing minors, harassing people to the point of suicide, putting someone’s entire life in the spotlight so their every word can be watched and judged, punishing people in the group for not conforming to their shitty ideals of “morality”, cutting someone’s entire support system just for having a “bad” ship, telling people they deserve to be killed and raped for making fanart and giving people with OCD constant morality obsessions definitely qualifies as fucking abuse.

I’ll give you the benefit of the doubt and assume you just don’t understand the scope of the harm I’m talking about, because if you knew about that and still decided to leave this in my inbox, then you are a vile fucking human for downplaying the harm that the purity police have caused to fandom communities and to internet spaces in general. They fucking destroyed me, just like the mormon church destroyed me, and I will never forgive them for making me spiral into oblivion over a fucking label that just means, “hey, maybe we should not harass people over FUCKING SHIPS”!!!

And I wasn’t even abused that badly! Most of it just shaped my ideas of fiction being directly connected to real morality, which aligned with what I already believed from mormonism, but many have it far FAR worse, usually trans people and people of color. Many have been harassed to the point of suicide, but many more were simply left with a broken puritan psyche that takes years and YEARS to fully deconstruct and makes you more vulnerable to other cults like neo-nazism and radical feminism.

When I was about 12, I was so ashamed of my budding fictional crush that I cried for three days. When I was 15, I was told that only a real pedophile would write underage fiction. When I was 18, I was afraid of my sexual thoughts, leftover shame from years of purity culture eating away at me until even when I was free, I wasn’t really free, constantly scared of being judged. It’s only within the past few years that I’ve finally moved on to fully accept my weirdness and my own “bad” thoughts. At that point, antis had contributed to my shame about as much as the mormon church had, by implying that thoughts lead directly to action, especially if they’re sexual thoughts, meaning bad thoughts make you a bad person.

If you don’t believe me about that abuse, just look at the tag “#anti recipes” here on tumblr. It doesn’t take long to find examples. Death/rape threats, general harassment, suicide baits, false allegations, and much more. You’ll find every kind of bigotry in vast volumes. I’ve seen racism, sexism, transphobia, antisemitism, ableism, literally any way you can be bigoted, they’ve done it, and they’ve done it in VAST volumes.

And people like you make it easier for them to do so, by downplaying that harm and trying to gaslight their targets into thinking it’s really not as bad as it is.

Don’t cite the ancient magic to me, witch. I was there when it was written. Now get out of my sight.